Quick Index
 Adult Industry News
Search AINews Database
Type Keyword or Phrase Here
Advertise with AINews Pornography feminists unshackle their desires and celebrate their sexuality in the patriarchal world

Front Page
Film News
Media News
Business News
Clubs & Appearances
Law & Politics
Internet & Mobile News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Movie Spotlight Reviews
Pornstar Pages
AINews Staff
Ad Rates
PR 101: Press Release Service

Porn for GEEKS! Meet me & my friends!

Join Tera Patrick

November 01, 1999 07:38pm
Judge Restores Museum Funding
Source: Court TV
by: Laura Barandes

(NEW YORK, NY) -- New York Mayor Rudolf Giuliani has seen his argument against the Brooklyn Museum of Art turned on its head. On Monday, U.S. District Judge Nina Gershon granted the museum's request for an preliminary injunction against the mayor and city officials. In her 40-page opinion, Judge Gershon concluded that the museum "has established irreparable harm and a likelihood of success on its First Amendment claim."

In many ways, Judge Gershon seemed to suggest that the mayor and city officials were themselves causing more harm to the social fabric than has the art they so ardently oppose.

In her opinion, the judge wrote that "the state court action was conceived and initiated as an instrument to pressure the Museum and to compel it to cancel the Exhibit or remove specific objectionable works, without any reasonable expectation by the City that it could prevail on the merits of an action for ejectment." This, the judge suggested, came at the deliberate expense of the First Amendment.

Judge Gershon's order bars the mayor from "taking steps to inflict any punishment, retaliation, discrimination or sanction" against the museum due to its controversial exhibit "Sensation."

"The judge is totally out of control," Giuliani said during an upstate New York outing. He accused Judge Gershon of "abandoning all reason under the guise of the First Amendment."

An attorney for the museum, Floyd Abrams, called Gershon's decision "a victory not only for the Brooklyn Museum but for the First Amendment rights for all of us."

The museum sued the city last month, claiming its First Amendment rights had been violated by Giuliani's decision to freeze a $7.2 million subsidy about a third of its annual budget. It sought the injunction to restore funds until the legal dispute could be settled.

The art war broke out at a Sept. 22 news conference, when the mayor called the exhibit of works by young British artists which features a portrait of the Virgin Mary adorned with elephant dung "sick," sacrilegious and unworthy of taxpayer support.

After the museum refused to cancel the show, the city withheld a $497,554 payment for October, then sued in state court to evict the museum from a city-owned site it has leased for more than 100 years.

At a hearing before Judge Gershon, Abrams accused the city of trying to punish free speech and called the city's behavior "a First Amendment catastrophe."

At one point in oral arguments, the city was asked whether it could similarly direct a library to remove what it deemed "offensive" or "objectional." Lawyers for the city argued that "the visual art in the Exhibit has a greater impact than do books."

In response and with a dry humor that leaks from the written decision counsel for the Museum "noted that books like Mein Kamph have done harm but are still protected by the First Amendment."

Moreover, in her decision, Judge Gershon wrote : "The communicative power of visual arts is not a basis for restricting it but rather the very reason it is protected by the First Amendment."

In fact, the City's own representative on the Museum's Board of Trustees wrote a letter months before "Sensation" came to town expressing interest in the Exhibit which he said seemed designed to "shake up New York's art world."

At least there is no argument about that.

City officials said they would appeal.

Advertise with AINews

Related Stories

Related Sites - WARNING! Graphic Content



Top Stories

MWA: 02/18/2018

Misty Stone Goes Mainstream

Black Loads Matter

Alexis Amore to Hall of Fame

Baumgartners Wins Best Polyamory

Ryder Wins Best Screenplay

PPK = Porn Party Karaoke

Losers Never Get Laid ~ Reviewer Rated

Pornstar Signature Series

LewdWork Adult Job Board

Scott Taylor Interview

MWA: 01/16/18

Happy New Year 2018

MWA: 12/26/17

MWA: 12/21/17

2018 AVN Awards Nominees

MWA: 12/16/17

MWA: 12/10/17

MWA: 12/09/17

A Season for Hope

MWA: 12/06/17

MWA: 12/05/17

Gonzo with Eddie Powell

Guild Demands New HIV Testing!

ED Award Winners

MWA: 11/07/17

Burlesque Documentary

Farrah Abraham Fired for Porn Return

Heaven and Hell 2017

Stories From

Law & Politics

Prop 60, Part One

Prop 60, Part Two

Official APAG Statement

Darling Running for Assembly

Possible Identity Theft

Bunny Ranch Special

Prop 60 Defeated

Tarts for Trump

Darcy Tyler Jailed

Weiner Offered Media Director

Julia Ann Against Prop 60

Pedophile Olympic Coaches Exposed

Law & Politics Section Index

Alice Polls Her Clients

What Prop 60 Really Is

IEAU Statement on Prop 60

FLOTUS Shatters Porn Search Records

Debbie Wasserman Schultz Offered $50K

Cruz Receives Porn Offer

Performers File Unpaid Wage Claims

Candidate Sex Tape Scandal

Donald Trump Porn Parody

Sex with Donald Trump

Hof Runs for Senate

Hookers for Hillary

Adult's Achilles Heel

AHF's Hidden Agenda

Pistol, Ross Talk Condoms

Modern Comstockery

Hof on Phoenix Hooker Bust

Cal/OSHA vs Evil Angel

Pornstar Graduates Law School

AHF Against AB 999

CraigsErotica Letter to Senators

Amazon Crushes Small Business

Letter of Equality

ASACP Service Recognition Award

Suit Filed Challenging Measure B

ASACP Ready For Internext

Octomom Loses Civil Suit


Crakmedia ASACP Corporate Sponsor

Mo Reese Statement

CAM4 Newest ASACP Sponsor

Takedown Piracy Removes 10,000,000

Three Stooges Porn Controversy

Suing: Wasn't Sexy Enough

Lords of Acid Censored

Nate Glass on CNBC

Copyright © 1998 - 2018 Adult Industry News (AINews.com)
All materials constituting text, articles, press releases, stories, columns, photographs, graphics, and code on the AINews.com domain are protected by copyright, and either owned by Adult Industry News (AINews.com), or reproduced with permission from other copyright owners. It may be downloaded and printed for personal reference, but not otherwise copied, altered in any way, or transmitted to others, without the written permission of Adult Industry News (AINews.com).